the goal size is 2 small

xOscar wrote:why didnt SH's accurate passing score vs C3 then? - Can't win every game. C3 had a good day, SS a bad one.

"aero just sed it the meta atm is to bus." - Aye, i agree. Never said it wasn't. And i think increasing the goal size will make people just bus harder. All out attack works in pubs, maybe you should stick to those kid.

"also, it WOULD make the skill ceiling higher, cus the only factor wont just be defence, but also attack." - You're missing the point B4d. Both are already "factors". C3 didn't defend at all last season, walked the league. Just learn how to attack, instead of pointless possession. Ie. Raise your skill level. Atm you're saying "I'm so far away from the skill ceiling can we lower it please".

"i clearly said, make it big as possible to the point of being impossible to score ONLY vs extremely high defence co-ordination and game sense." - Nonsense man. You're acting like it's physically impossible to beat a good bus. 36 goals in 10 games.. Very, very few clean sheets! You're whole argument is based on "i think we deserve more goals for how we play, make the goals bigger for us, oh and somehow that makes this ridiculous obsession i have with a skill ceiling higher". Ridiculous.

"what would this do? the better ur attack, the more mistakes u would capitalise on = higher skill ceiling" - Absolute nonsense man! This is already true at the current goal size. The better your attack the more chances you capitalise on. Obviously. However making the goal size bigger just means those who aren't as good at attacking are more likely to score. And those who are actually good at attacking would of scored anyway! Bigger goals just rewards those who less ruthless upfront. Thus lowering the skill ceiling.

"the better ur defence, the less opportunities for opponent = higher skill ceiling" - Again, already true at the current goal size, and again increasing the goal size just means that people will learn to defend better, and those who can defend better are rewarded far more then those who can attack (see above). So yes this will increase the skill ceiling for defending but that's not what you want! You wanted to increase the attack! Not make people learn how to bus better!

Yes there are some counter arguments, but IMO they aren't anywhere near as strong as you're making them out to be. And it certainly isn't as straightforward as "bigger goals = better skill required", if anything it's the opposite.

Point being, -1 + 1 does not = 2.


xx

Yawn wrote:Sure, the dm cant overcommit in 3v3 because then he will conced a open net, but the defending team has no striker to lock the ball upfield like in 3def. Therefor, if you plan to bus you will be in def for the full game, and eventually the ball will find its way in.

Keep in mind also that the goals you score vs buses isnt really cool youtube plays, instead its 2-3 fast passings and then you tap in the rebound or something when its chaotic in def, or atleast thats how i experienced it so far in hax vs busses.